04-10-2003, 01:31 AM
I don't know. Clay definitely has an amazing voice, but I don't think he's "commercial" enough (to use a word Simon used to define Carmen). I agree Josh should head to Nashville. I can't believe they voted Rickey out and kept Carmen. Kimberly Caldwell should make it another week or two, same with Trenyce. Kimberly Locke just doesn't do it for me. She's got a nice voice, but not too much else. Ruben is my choice for mainstream idol. Josh would get my vote for country idol. Clay gets my vote for the Barry Manilow-type idol.