Greatest athlete ever - Choose one.

[GonzoStyle]

I noticed you didn't mention one female in the poll...

Please....

Jackie Robinson was a good ball player but not extraordinary in anyway, whatsoever. Willie Mays, mantle, all those people were exceptional players but not "great".

Gretzky on the other hand, the argument can be made, I just won't make it. All you gotta know is how many records the man shares and owns and that speaks for itself.