why the yanks wont win

[GonzoStyle]

He's a good offensive player but the whole point is that if he wasn't a catcher his numbers wouldn't be notable, they'd be decent numbers. He never justified himself as a catcher, the same way A Rod was never really a true short stop, though he atleast played the position very well as did Magic Johnson. You never mention Piazza in the same category as a Bench or Berra.