2005 AL MVP - Who should it be and why?

[GonzoStyle]

A rod over ortiz, while both are almost equals on offense, ortiz is still a DH. Plus A Rod has become more clutch than he was last season and is tops in almost all offensive categories, if Ortiz played defense though i'd have to give it to him. The award may probably be decided between the 2 on how they perform in the final series this weekend is some eyes but A Rod has the edge.