Star wars episode two thoughts

[IkeaBoy]

good cgi effects do not make a good movie.

I cannot agree with this statement enough. The best 'proof' of this is just thinking about the Jabba from Special Edition and TPM and the Jabba from Jedi. CGI still doesn't have the realism needed to totally work for me. Jedi's Jabba was a huge monstrous creature who above all things was REAL. You can't duplicate his drool and ooze with a couple of key strokes. I understand you can do a lot more with CGI than with models but you lose a lot as well.