Mattingly in a yankee uniform again - its all over

[Goatweed]

your words cut like a knife - the pain!!!

[GonzoStyle]

There's just things I will never fathom.

People who think Reagan was the greatest president ever, people who think andy warhol was a genius, people who think the stones are better than the beatles and people who think Mattingly was a great player, even worse the people who think he deserves to be in cooperstown. The only way Mattingly deserves enterance into cooperstown is by buying a ticket.

[The Sleeper]

The only way Mattingly deserves enterance into cooperstown is by buying a ticket.

Kirby Puckett's lifetime stats: .318 207 HRs 1085 RBIs
Mattingly's lifetime stats .307 222 HRs 1099 RBIs

Puckett was a first ballot hall of famer

[GonzoStyle]

Cause he won the big one, with his bat.

[The Sleeper]

no one player wins anything, even if he gets the game winning hit. Also, Mattingly was a great defensive 1st baseman. if you thought puckett deserved to get in, i don't see how it's unfathomable that mattingly deserves it.

[Galt]

Who the fuck thought that Puckett should get in?

Mattingly as his peak was infinitely better than Puckett at his peak. Mattingly just was only great for like five years. Like Dante Bichett.e

[The Sleeper]

Who the fuck thought that Puckett should get in?

the hall of fame committee. and Dante Bichette had all his good years in Colorado, negating everything.

[Galt]

Puckett doesn't belong there, at all. It should only be white people.

[GonzoStyle]

Albert Belle had a better streak.

[HedCold]

he shaved his mustache

[Galt]

Seriously, in the mid 90s, there was no better baseball player.

[The Sleeper]

Dante Bichette wasn't that good!

[GonzoStyle]

What's scary now is that the talk is that they didn't really care about him being the batting coach. The real reason was that they basically took him in to be Torres replacement.

Basically willie randolph gets promoted to bench coach now to replace zimmer. Ofcourse randolph is fucked, even if Torre leaves after next season, Mattingly may not be prepared to take over as manager and they may give it to Randolph. Then randolph is more fucked cause not only does he have to replace the NY god that Torre is, he has Mattingly breathing down his neck the 1st time willie fucks up.

[Goatweed]

Mattingly would make a fine skipper - just not right now.

[GonzoStyle]

Boston fans will rejoice if Mattingly takes over as skipper, cause former players who take over as managers do so well.

The yanks won't see the playoffs, maybe on a wildcard and then get knocked out in the 1st round.

It's over if donnie fucknuts takes over.

[The Sleeper]

cause former players who take over as managers do so well.

yea cause Joe Torre didn't play or anything

[Keyser Soze]

i agree mattingly is overrated, but a prick? he seems like a swell guy. and this is coming from a mets fan.

[Goatweed]

he's just a hater, pay him no mind.

[The Sleeper]

He's pushing buttons!!!

[HedCold]

when do scott brosious and paul oneil get brought back to coach?