Your Turn To Play God - a hypothetical situation

[Faceman]

The scenario isn't really hypothetical being that this situation, or ones like it, have occurred throughout our history from time to time I'm sure. It's not right and it's not fair, but "good people" in this world are going to suffer while others who are not as desirable, live their lives under the radar and live passable lives until they die. It's called life, it's been going on for ages and will continue to go on. That stated, I agree with OAS in that B is the scenario that must be chosen if you are a follower of god's teaching. We would like to believe that A would always be true, but that's not always the case